Prop 65 notice 2018-01640: Endangered Species Chocolate
As You Sow filed this California Prop 65 60-day notice on August 31, 2018. It names Endangered Species Chocolate, Equal Exchange, Inc., Madecasse, LLC, Theo Chocolate, Inc., Vosges Haut-Chocolat, Alfred Ritter GmbH & Co. KG, Chocolat Bernrain AG, Fuchs & Hoffmann GmbH, Machu Picchu Foods SAC, Maestrani Schweizer Schokoladen AG, Olam Americas, Inc., Puratos Group NV, Schokinag-Schokolade-Industrie GmbH, Chocolat Frey AG, First Source, LLC and Fran’s Chocolates, Ltd. and alleges exposure to Cadmium and Lead from Dark Chocolate Bar, 88% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Endangered Species Chocolates [lead], Organic & Fairly Traded Dark Chocolate Bar, Ecuador, 65% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Equal Exchange, Inc. [cadmium], Dark Chocolate Bar, 80% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Madecasse, LLC [lead], Dark Chocolate for Baking Bar, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Theo Chocolate, Inc. [lead and cadmium], Smoked Salt Super Dark Bar, 80% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Vosges Haut-Chocolat [lead], Ritter Sport Fine Extra Dark Chocolate Bar, 73% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Alfred Ritter GmbH & Co. KG [cadmium], Chocolat Stella Noir Extra Dark Chocolate Bar, Costa Rica, 75% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Chocolat Bernrain AG [cadmium], Cocoa liquor WA/Peru, 100% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Fuchs & Hoffman GmbH [lead and cadmium], Pascha Organic Dark Chocolate Chips, Bitter-Sweet, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Machu Picchu Foods SAC [cadmium], Schmerling’s of Switzerland Extra Dark Finest Swiss Chocolate Bar, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Maestrani Schweizer Schokoladen AG [cadmium], deZaan Cacao Powder, 100% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Olam Americas, Inc. [cadmium], Belcolade Cocoa Butter & Natural Vanilla Noir Powder, Peru, 64.5% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Puratos Group NV [cadmium], Dark Chocolate Couverture, 59% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Schokinag-Schokolade-Industrie GmbH [lead], Signature Select Dark Chocolate Bar, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Chocolat Frey AG [cadmium], Premium Baking Unsweetened Cocoa Powder, 100% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by First Source, LLC [lead], Fran’s Dark Hot Chocolate Powder, Single Origin Venezuelan, 65% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Fran’s Chocolate Ltd. [cadmium].
The violations below are alleged in a 60-day notice. They are not proven. A 60-day notice is not a lawsuit and not a finding of liability.
- AG number
- 2018-01640
- Date filed
- Noticing party
- Plaintiff attorney
- Sylvia Wu
- Alleged violators
- Endangered Species Chocolate
- Equal Exchange, Inc.
- Madecasse, LLC
- Theo Chocolate, Inc.
- Vosges Haut-Chocolat
- Alfred Ritter GmbH & Co. KG
- Chocolat Bernrain AG
- Fuchs & Hoffmann GmbH
- Machu Picchu Foods SAC
- Maestrani Schweizer Schokoladen AG
- Olam Americas, Inc.
- Puratos Group NV
- Schokinag-Schokolade-Industrie GmbH
- Chocolat Frey AG
- First Source, LLC
- Fran’s Chocolates, Ltd.
- Source or product
- Dark Chocolate Bar, 88% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Endangered Species Chocolates [lead], Organic & Fairly Traded Dark Chocolate Bar, Ecuador, 65% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Equal Exchange, Inc. [cadmium], Dark Chocolate Bar, 80% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Madecasse, LLC [lead], Dark Chocolate for Baking Bar, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Theo Chocolate, Inc. [lead and cadmium], Smoked Salt Super Dark Bar, 80% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Vosges Haut-Chocolat [lead], Ritter Sport Fine Extra Dark Chocolate Bar, 73% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Alfred Ritter GmbH & Co. KG [cadmium], Chocolat Stella Noir Extra Dark Chocolate Bar, Costa Rica, 75% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Chocolat Bernrain AG [cadmium], Cocoa liquor WA/Peru, 100% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Fuchs & Hoffman GmbH [lead and cadmium], Pascha Organic Dark Chocolate Chips, Bitter-Sweet, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Machu Picchu Foods SAC [cadmium], Schmerling’s of Switzerland Extra Dark Finest Swiss Chocolate Bar, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Maestrani Schweizer Schokoladen AG [cadmium], deZaan Cacao Powder, 100% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Olam Americas, Inc. [cadmium], Belcolade Cocoa Butter & Natural Vanilla Noir Powder, Peru, 64.5% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Puratos Group NV [cadmium], Dark Chocolate Couverture, 59% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Schokinag-Schokolade-Industrie GmbH [lead], Signature Select Dark Chocolate Bar, 85% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Chocolat Frey AG [cadmium], Premium Baking Unsweetened Cocoa Powder, 100% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by First Source, LLC [lead], Fran’s Dark Hot Chocolate Powder, Single Origin Venezuelan, 65% Cacao, which is manufactured, distributed and/or sold in California by Fran’s Chocolate Ltd. [cadmium]
- Official notice
- Notice PDF at oag.ca.gov
- Official record
- Attorney General record for 2018-01640
- Last checked
- November 11, 2026
What happened after this notice
Outcomes for this notice have not been checked yet. A settlement is not an admission and not a finding that anyone broke the law.
Recent notices filed by As You Sow
- Colson Health, Inc. and 1 more: Lead, Lead and lead compounds in Lactation Bars and shakesNotice 2024-01991, filed 2024-05-20 by As You Sow
- Etsy, Inc.: Mercury, Mercury and mercury compounds in Skin-lightening, whitening, and “smoothing” creams containing 1 ppm or more mercury or mercury compounds.Notice 2024-01113, filed 2024-03-15 by As You Sow
- Etsy, Inc.: Mercury, Mercury and mercury compounds in Skin-lightening, whitening, and “smoothing” creams containing 1 ppm or more mercury or mercury compounds.Notice 2024-00232, filed 2024-01-18 by As You Sow
- AMAZON.COM, INC.: Mercury and mercury compounds in SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, GOREE BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, FACE FRESH BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, NUNN CARE BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, CHANDNI BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, POLLA BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, CREMA LA MILAGROSA BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, PIEL ETERNAMENTE JOVEN BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDS, NATURAL FACE BRAND SKIN-LIGHTENING, WHITENING AND "SMOOTHING" CREAMS CONTAINING MERCURY OR MERCURY COMPOUNDSNotice 2023-01553, filed 2023-06-02 by AS YOU SOW
- Amazon.com, Inc.: Mercury and mercury compounds in Nunn Care Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Faiza Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Aneeza Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Be Be Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Be Be Special Skin Lightening Cosmetics, CCM Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Chandni Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Dr. Yanhee Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Face Fresh Beauty Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Goree Skin Lightening Cosmetics, KIM Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Parley Skin Lightening Cosemetics (non-English label), Glutinone Skin Lightening Cosmetics, Sandal Skin Lightening CosmeticsNotice 2023-01162, filed 2023-05-01 by As You Sow